exoray wrote:
Honestly AA will say anything and change as necessary to back his story, even the Judge pointed this out... AA's helmets if they originate from any part of the original mold, then the mold has be revised and rebuilt creating many distinct differences, making it a totally different beast in the end... He even revised his story about the molds several times as differences were pointed out, and to this date can't explain where the 'swoop' went on the back of the helmet...
Sorry to anyone that has or had a glimpse of hope, hold on to it if you must, but IMO there is NO way AA's parts originated from original molds... The only part that I have any hesitation towards would be the face plate, but even that hesitation is small as I believe it is more likely derived from a casting taken of one of his "prototype" helmets prior to him selling them off...
You know full well you can't argue that. The judge said nothing about the molds being original or not. It's still an open question. You can argue it from the standpoint of your impression of accuracy, but not from a legal one. The judge never stated "you don't have the original molds, so you don't have copyright".
Quote:
Be that as it may, Mr Wilson, on behalf of Mr Ainsworth, did not dispute that the helmet thus produced (and the final version) was a substantial reproduction of the McQuarrie material for copyright purposes; and Lucas did not dispute that some of the detail on the prototype and the final version was created by Mr Ainsworth. I received a lot of evidence from Mr Ainsworth as to how precisely he first produced his own version of the helmet, and how he then went on to make the various moulds which he used for vacuum-forming the five parts which made up the whole. In the end little of that detail mattered, in relation to the Stormtrooper helmet. What is important is the source of its design.
So the molds didn't matter, it was the final product that resembled the McQuarrie design.
And I've already shown how many times the prototype helmet interior doesn't match the AA interior, nor is it as sharp as the AA. Where it came from I have no idea. I'm not saying the molds are original, just that I don't think he got them from the prototype. He stated they needed repair and that probably led to the changes.